yo Mike,
Do you use clutch to downshift?
If not, try clutching.
A
GUESS - the synchros
---
Known problems include:
leaks from shift rail plugs #481 & 484 (see them in Parts Break-Out Diagram below; M5ODs have a habit of leaking out fluid when the rubber plugs on the top of the tranmission fall apart)
***** &/or master cylinder
sensitivity to fluid level & quality
weak shifter susceptible to wear
I'll give you the relevant info I have in case others here have better info on those symptoms:
Clutch Noise
Insufficient clutch pedal free play.
Damaged clutch release hub and bearing.
Poor lubrication of clutch release hub and bearing sleeve.
Damaged or worn transmission input shaft pilot bearing.
Worn pivot points or clutch release lever (if equipped).
Excessive crankshaft end play.
GO to Pinpoint Test H.
---------------
As for replacing the M5OD; read this article;
M5OD 5 Speed Transmission Overview
Source: by Mike W
http://www.rsgear.com/articles/1993_11.pdf
such as;
make sure donor is for 4 wheel drive
check ID Tag located on the driver's side of the cass to ensure it is compatible
------------
M5OD Parts Break-Out Diagram w/ Nomenclature
https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:kdW5pElLiqwJ:www.transtar1.com/catDownload.asp?ID%3D609+M5R2+Shift+Stick&hl=en&gl=us&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEEShXrfPqvtgCgNzB-a9FN3uwWkKdfIy6_x0iqbfTXcfvlTx5GjkRD3lSixh4Gel6VvGpPAuzVQdAdubL8ZQD6J8oKURIqppaJeOyi8gsDeab45nxsZzqD2upvX_Lw60OTYlC52Is&sig=AHIEtbShppkjurNmJP4Xnhp57p1_67bPtA
===
Shifter **** is pressed-on
To remove the shifter, remove the 17mm nut from the passenger side of the stud, and install it on the driver's side. Tighten it until it loosens, then push the stud out to the driver's side. Remove the shifter.
---------
M5OD Disassembly & Assembly Procedures in a 95
M5OD Disassembly & Assembly of Sub-Assemblies in a 94
-------
M5OD 5 Speed Transmission Disc, Pressure Plate & ***** Cylinder Replacement & Parts Break-Out Diagram in 96 Bronco& F-150, F-250, F-350, F-Super Duty Chassis Cab; Miesk5 Note, Ford often calls it the R2 or M5OD-R2 transmission
Same for your year.
---------
SBW12 wrote;
Chatter could be the shift forks. Mine were pretty wore out but I didn't care, I went the ZF5 route. It's a direct bolt in and a much better tranny with granny low and taller OD.. Those forks aren't too hard to replace because they are attached to the top cover and you can get to it through the tranny tunnel, don't even have to drop the transmission
S5-47 Swap pics from M5OD in a 95
Source: by Pepper (J A F O, Big Pig) at
http://www.supermotors.net/clubs/superford/registry/37/18885